Home > Sugar Free Pies & Tarts > Sugar Free Pumpkin and Squash Pies

Sugar Free Pumpkin and Squash Pies

By: Mary Williams BA (hons) - Updated: 3 Oct 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie Recipe Pumpkin

Pumpkin and squash pies may have originally been American favourites but these days they are becoming more popular in the UK too.These sugar free versions make great autumnal dishes and are obviously ideal for Halloween when the flesh from the inside of your lanterns and decorations needs to be eaten up.Pumpkins and squashes can be perfect fillings for sugar free pies as they are already so naturally sweet. Simply add a little honey to give them a boost, spice them up a little with nutmeg, cinnamon and other spices - and your filling has almost made itself!

Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie

Find a nice ripe pumpkin for this recipe. Ensure you have scraped out all the seeds then cut the flesh away, leaving the skin in tact to shape into a lantern.

Ingredients:

For The Pastry:

  • 400g (14oz) plain flour
  • 200g (7oz) soft margarine
  • One tbsp cold water

For The Filling:

  • 400g (14oz) pumpkin flesh
  • Two large eggs
  • Three tbsps honey
  • One tsp ground cinnamon
  • One tsp ground allspice
  • One tsp ground ginger
  • 250ml double cream

Method:

Pre-heat your oven to 180 deg C/350 deg F/gas mark four. Take a tablespoon of your flour and put it into a bowl with your soft margarine and cold water. Take a fork and gently mash it together until you have a paste. Slowly add the rest of your flour until you have a dough that has a delicate pastry-like consistency. Wrap it in cling film then place in the fridge.

Meanwhile, chop your pumpkin flesh into chunks and place in a large saucepan. Cover with water and bring to the boil. Simmer gently until the pumpkin is soft, then remove from the heat, drain and tip into a large bowl to cool. Beat your eggs in a separate bowl. Take your honey and place in a medium pan. Heat gently (stirring all the time) and allow to melt. Slowly add your spices and cream.

By now, your pastry should be firmer. Remove from the fridge and roll out on a surface that has been lightly dusted with flour. Grease an 18" pie tin and line with your pastry. Bake blind for just five minutes until the pastry case starts going golden brown.

Tip your honey and cream mixture and your eggs into the large bowl with the pumpkin in. Whiz all the ingredients together with a hand blender then pour into the pastry case. Bake in the centre of the over for about half an hour or until the filling is nice and firm. Remove from the heat, allow to cool and serve with more cream.

Butternut Squash Pie

This sugar free recipe is delicious with butternut squash but do experiment with other squashes too. The pie can be served hot or cold.

Ingredients:

For The Pastry:

  • 400g (14oz) plain flour
  • 200g (7oz) soft margarine
  • One tbsp cold water

For The Filling:

  • 400g (14oz) butternut squash flesh
  • Two large eggs
  • Three tbsps honey
  • One tsp ground cinnamon
  • One tsp ground allspice
  • One tsp vanilla essence
  • 500g cream cheese

Method:

Once again pre-heat your oven to 180 deg C/350 deg F/gas mark four. Then, to make your pastry, follow the recipe above for Sugar Free Pumpkin.

To make your filling, however, remove your butternut squash flesh, taking care not to include any seeds, chop into pieces and simmer in boiling water until soft. Then place in a bowl to cool. Beat your eggs in a separate bowl.

Once again, melt your honey and spices together over a gentle heat. This time, whiz all your ingredients together in a large bowl with your cream cheese and vanilla essence as well. Spoon into your partly baked pastry case and place in the centre of the oven for about half an hour.

Remove from the heat when the filling is firm and serve with cream or sugar free ice-cream.

Related Articles in the 'Sugar Free Pies & Tarts' Category...
Topics
Comments
  • Lee
    Re: Sugar Free Halloween Cakes
    The devils delight no sugar cake is more like a brownie. Help
    23 September 2017
  • The999baker
    Re: No Sugar Sponge Cakes
    Instead of honey use xylitol. Perfect for diabetics and tastes as good as refined sugar. Add some vanilla as well for a bit of taste
    21 September 2017
  • OviAviation
    Re: No Sugar Sponge Cakes
    3 tbs Honey = 51 grams sugar. I'm diabetic so this recipe would be a disaster.
    12 September 2017
  • ZoeMarie
    Re: Sugar Free Cup Cakes
    Just tried the vanilla cupcake recipe , absolutely awful quantities all wrong too much butter not enough flour or sweetener they came out…
    25 August 2017
  • JM44
    Re: Sugar Free Brownies
    I read the comments about the brownies being dry and bitter so I added an extra egg and doubled the honey. Then I had to drizzle honey over…
    24 August 2017
  • SugarFreeRecipes
    Re: Naturally Sweet Fruit Loaves
    JM44 - Your Question:Do you have the nutritional values for the sugar free recipes?Our Response:
    23 August 2017
  • JM44
    Re: Naturally Sweet Fruit Loaves
    Do you have the nutritional values for the sugar free recipes?
    21 August 2017
  • Lesley tilbury
    Re: No Sugar Sponge Cakes
    Made sponge cake came out like a pudding tasted nice but not right...i cooked it on 180 for 30 mins it didnt say what to put oven on ????…
    20 August 2017
  • SugarFreeRecipes
    Re: Sugar Free Tarte Tartin
    lynds985 - Your Question:Hello, You do not mention how to use the 85g butter for the topping?and how does the tartin not get completely…
    17 August 2017
  • lynds985
    Re: Sugar Free Tarte Tartin
    Hello, You do not mention how to use the 85g butter for the topping? and how does the tartin not get completely stuck in the tin? I…
    15 August 2017